Welcome to Manitou Baked
Nestled in the heart of Manitou Springs, Colorado, Manitou Baked is a charming, family-owned pizzeria renowned for its exceptional homemade sourdough crust. Customers rave about the authentic and generous toppings that elevate each slice to culinary delight. The warm, laid-back atmosphere, highlighted by nostalgic VHS movie displays, makes it an ideal spot for families and couples alike. Patrons appreciate the unassuming storefront and friendly service, with many expressing disbelief at the low prices for such top-quality pizza. With rave reviews affirming its status as a must-visit, Manitou Baked promises an unforgettable dining experience in a cozy setting.
-
112 Ruxton Ave, Manitou Springs, CO 80829, United States Hotline: +1 719-351-8762
Welcome to Manitou Baked, a hidden gem nestled at 112 Ruxton Ave in the picturesque locale of Manitou Springs, Colorado. This cozy, family-owned establishment has quickly earned a reputation for delivering some of the finest pizzas in the state. With an emphasis on quality ingredients and a unique twist on classic recipes, Manitou Baked exudes a warmth that invites you to linger.
The heart of their menu lies in the handmade sourdough crust. Made fresh each morning, this crust boasts an irresistible texture that finds the perfect balance between crispness and chewiness. Patrons rave about the generous toppings that accompany every pizza; the delightful “cheese pull” captures the essence of indulgence, making it the ideal Instagram moment. Each slice is topped with a vibrant, flavorful sauce that enhances the overall experience without overwhelming the palate.
Customer feedback speaks volumes. As one visitor, Maddy Hennessy, expressed, “1000/10 would recommend” this establishment. She fondly mentioned the nostalgic ambiance created by the collection of VHS movies, making it a suitable spot for families and couples alike. The cozy seating arrangement, albeit small, adds to the charm, encouraging diners to embrace a sense of community.
Accessibility and affordability are also highlights here. With prices that surprise patrons like Jenevieve Hornsby—who shared her appreciation for the affordable menu—Manitou Baked makes gourmet pizza approachable for everyone. Sharie W. extols the cozy atmosphere, where you can unwind with family or friends, ensuring there’s a delicious slice waiting for everyone.
But it’s not just about the food. The owners are known for their friendly and down-to-earth demeanor, fostering a welcoming environment that resonates with guests. Chef Eddie Boy is noted for crafting pizzas on-the-fly, earning rave reviews, including from Stephen Eshelman, who lauded a pie that he ranked among the best he's ever had. The personalized service and atmosphere enhance the overall dining experience, making it not just a meal, but a memory.
If you find yourself in Manitou Springs, stepping into Manitou Baked is a must. Experience the magic of fresh ingredients, handmade crust, and a welcoming atmosphere that beckons you to return. Whether you're a local or a traveler, this is a dining experience that will linger long after your visit.
Cozy family owned establishment. Really great pizza! Homemade sourdough crust
1000/10 would recommend to a friend! The best pizza I have had in all of Colorado. Staff and owner were super friendly. Sourdough crust made from scratch that morning, the cheese pull was Instagram-worthy, and the sauce left the most delicious taste in my mouth- I didn’t want to eat anything else for hours. Huge collection of nostalgic vhs movies on display brought a laid-back, cozy atmosphere. Perfect for both families or couples on a casual nights out. Also, shockingly low prices. We got three slices of pizza and paid 8 out the door. I cannot talk this place up enough!!!
Pizza was authentic and top quality ingredients. Exceptional taste! If I was a local, this would be my go-to for pizza. It’s kind of off the beaten path, but we found it so others can, too. Highly recommend
Here to add to the slew of five star reviews — Manitou Baked deserves every one of them! We were visiting the area last week and in search of good pizza. We definitely found it! The storefront is unassuming — we actually thought the restaurant was closed at first — but just as everyone said, in about 20 minutes we had made-to-order pizza with incredibly generous toppings and delicious sourdough crust. We went on a Friday night and while there were a few other orders in the works, I am so confused about why this place didn’t have a line out the door and around the block! If we are ever visiting Manitou Springs again, we will be back!
Barstool sports the guy that owns it does pizza reviews. I’ve seen him do them all over the country everywhere to all the best places for pizza. When he does the rating of the pizza they have to be crisp with a perfect undercarriage right amount of flop and so on. Check out the videos...If you go to manitou baked it’s not about when they’re expecting you, It’s about when they’re not Eddie boy made me a pizza on the fly that was easily in the top five I’ve ever had in my life. You should get over there.
The owner is super cool and down to earth, the pizza was great and freshly prepared in less than 25 mins. We really enjoyed it and the price wasn’t bad. Highly Recommend!
What a great find! Reviews were all 5 stars, and they are 10 stars. It was a short walk up from town and worth every step. Restaurant is small with a couple of tables and chairs, but why not sit in one of the nearby parks and enjoy the outdoors? We got the added pleasure during our visit to speak with one of the owners and their mother. Shared stories about the business, Manitua area, and where we lived. The pizza was amazing, and I have had my share of pizzas. There were 2 unique features of this pizza.The first was hand-made sour dough crust and how thin it was. I usually don't eat the pizza crust b/c it is all bread and fills you up. The pizza and toppings went to the edge, and I ate every bit of it. Second was the red sauce. Fresh pieces of garlic and the right amount of sauce that didn't over take the flavor of the toppings. I know it is away from downtown but you have to go there. We are already looking forward to our return trip when the Aspens start to turn. Checked the box, and I'll be back.
ABSOLUTELY THE BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD The sauce was incredible The guys there were very, very nice & friendly. They have amazing paintings from local artists for sale. I highly recommend & will definitely be back.